The Pollock Petition: What Rohan Murthy Missed

Let us be clear: the online petition signed by 132 Indian intellectuals and academicians, asking Rohan Murthy and his father, NR Narayana Murthy, to remove Sheldon Pollock as editor of the Murthy Classical Library Project at Harvard is DOA – dead on arrival. To ask a private millionaire to fire his own hire and who is paid for from private wealth is hardly the right thing to do. In any case, it won’t work.

The Murthy Classical Library project is about translating Indian literary classics into English, and Sheldon Pollock is an “American Orientalist” who would like Western scholars to tutor Indians on how to read their own classical literature, including Sanskrit literature, preferably negatively. Pollock is against the revival of Sanskrit, and would like to treat this mother of Indian languages as a dead cultural heritage, which can be dissected by Western scholars in their own orientalist way, as Rajiv Malhotra noted in his book, The Battle For Sanskrit.

As this writer noted while reviewing Malhotra’s book:

The online petition asking Murthy to get rid of Pollock may be infructuous, since it has focused on an individual rather than the root problem: the inbuilt colonised mindset of Indians, which leads them to reward the Harvards and Yales with their endowments instead of strengthening classical studies in India, in Indian institutions.

Murthy, for example, donated $5.2 million to Harvard University to establish the classical library in 2010. He could have done more to develop the expertise back home. This project should have been used as an opportunity to build/rebuild India’s own pride in the past, and reinventing cultural values in a modern format, but it is instead enriching the West to denigrate us. The online petition notes Pollock’s “deep antipathy towards many ideals and values cherished and practiced in our civilisation. He echoes the views of Macaulay and Max Weber that the shastras generated in India serve no contemporary purpose except for the study of how Indians express themselves”.

Ratan Tata gifted $50 million to Harvard for a new building to house their new executive education centre. Anand Mahindra gave Harvard $10 million for a humanities centre. Sanjeev K Mehra of Goldman Sachs gave away $4 million to create a South Asian Chair at Harvard. The Birlas have ties with the London Business School through their investment in the Aditya Birla India Centre.

There is no point railing against Murthy alone if India’s wealthied class get their kicks from giving money to their alma maters when they should be doing more to develop intellectual capital back home.