Explained: Atmospheric Water Generation For Dummies

In the clip, Modi can be heard saying "... in places where there is higher level of moisture, wind turbines can extract water from the atmosphere and could produce clean drinking water. Thus, wind turbines can produce power and on the backside, suck moisturised air and extract water."

Modi cited the utility of such a mechanism in coastal areas and villages where drinking water was scarce.

Modi then called for research into using wind turbines to extract oxygen from the atmosphere. He said it would be challenging "but if a wind turbine extracts oxygen from the atmosphere... and the market for oxygen is captured, then wind turbines can be used for providing drinking water, oxygen and power supply." Thus, said Modi, a wind turbine could become a "three-in-one" system.

The CEO of Vestas responded enthusiastically to Modi for his suggestions and lauded his "passion" and "excitement".

Rahul tweeted the clip with the caption, "The real danger to India isn’t that our PM doesn’t understand. It’s the fact that nobody around him has the guts to tell him", starting a trolling attack over the comments.

But are PM Modi’s comments outlandish?

The Week reported that almost a decade ago, in 2012, a French company, Eole Water, claimed to have modified a wind turbine to extract water from humid air.

The wind turbine design was called the WMS1000. At the time, Eole Water claimed that a prototype of the WMS1000 was being tested in a desert near Abu Dhabi and was able to produce 62 litres of water an hour.

This way, the moisture is extracted from the air, condensed and collected. The water thus generated is then transferred through stainless steel pipes, filtered and purified for consumption.

Eole Water had claimed the WMS1000 could produce up to 1,000 litres of water a day, which was enough for a small community of up to 3,000 people.

However, the process is costly.

A 2012 CNN report said that "it costs between €500,000 ($660,000) and €600,000 ($790,000) depending on the location and surrounding conditions to install just one Eole Water turbine".

However, the area continues to be promising with several researchers further exploring the technology. Same is the case with the idea of oxygen extraction through wind turbines, which is more complicated than water extraction.

The idea is to harness wind energy to carry out electrolysis of water to generate hydrogen and oxygen. Researchers in the US and Europe have been conducting research on this for years. The purpose is to generate adequate hydrogen for renewable energy purposes.

If successful, a "three-in-one" wind turbine system could solve the water and energy woes of a community in a sustainable manner with lesser impact on the environment.