Newsletters

@Evening: 🤔 Now We Know Who Was Responsible For MVA Government Collapse

Karan KambleMay 11, 2023, 08:22 PM | Updated 08:22 PM IST
Story hero image



Uddhav Thackeray, former chief minister of Maharashtra

It's clear now: The Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government collapsed because of Uddhav Thackeray, specifically because he resigned.

Context: A Supreme Court bench led by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud today ruled on the pleas related to the June 2022 political crisis in Maharashtra.

  • The MVA government cannot be restored now since Thackeray resigned voluntarily and did not face a floor test.

  • Had Thackeray not resigned, the apex court said it could have restored the status quo.

  • Further, because of the resignation, the governor was proved right in inviting the Eknath Shinde-led coalition to form the government.

  • This also means now that Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde gets to keep his job.

  • Thackeray vs Shinde. The SC ruling has brought forth the realisation that Thackeray's move was not a mature one.

    • Everyone, including his allies from the Congress and NCP, had already expressed their displeasure over his resignation.

  • Thackeray likely acted without consultation with his own party people, an accusation he faced during the entire rebellion.

  • As for Shinde, he received a seal of approval today from the top court to stay on as the CM.

  • This is a booster shot for Shinde, who already had a win when the Election Commission granted him the party.

  • Shinde will now use the symbol and party name without any issue.


  • What does this mean for MH politics? Today's verdict may make the already nervous allies, especially the NCP, even more nervous.

    • They might even be closer to quitting the alliance at this point.

  • Even the Congress, perhaps, wouldn’t want to be seen with a leader who caused his own government’s collapse.

  • Plus, Thackeray met Nitish Kumar today at his home in Mumbai.

  • Kumar, as many speculate, aspires to be the PM face of the opposition, but the Congress is not on board with it.

  • Thackeray has also got newer allies of whom the NCP is wary.

  • All this is causing further trouble in an already tenuous relationship among MVA allies.

  • Bottom line: After today's verdict, it is likely that the political centre of the Shiv Sena will move from Matoshree to Shinde’s Sena Bhawan. 

    • Maharashtra politics is changing, and a new leader is taking over the Shiv Sena, a party that has dominated the scene for a long time.

  • Surprisingly, it won't be a Thackeray leading the change this time around.

  • Join our WhatsApp channel - no spam, only sharp analysis