Politics
Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah. (Hemant Mishra/Mint via Getty Images)
The Siddaramaiah government in Karnataka, after pointlessly trying to blame the Centre for not giving it rice from the central pool for free distribution, has correctly decided to pay cash amounting to Rs 170 per head per month instead of the promised 5 kg of rice.
The Centre was right to refuse the Karnataka demand, given the possibility, even probability, of a weak monsoon this year.
Depleting existing stocks of rice (around 26 million tonnes currently), when kharif production could be lower than hoped for, would be foolish when food prices are anyway elevated. And it does not matter whether or not the current stocks are higher than the prescribed minimum buffer of 13.5 million tonnes.
In the event of a crop failure, it is not only Karnataka, but every other state, that will be drawing on central stocks to feed the poor. And market prices will surely rise if traders and growers suspect that a shortage looms.
So, no, Karnataka was not entitled to any special supply of rice from the central pool, and that too for free distribution.
However, the idea of giving cash instead of a bag of rice is good in itself. For three reasons.
First, cash in hand gives beneficiaries the choice of using it for other purposes, including education of children and healthcare.
Second, payments in kind often end up distorting the market, as the recipient often sells the same rice for cash. So, it is far better to give the cash directly than to force the beneficiary to encash the freebie in the market.
Third, cash changes the nature of the benefactor-beneficiary relationship. It makes the beneficiary a consumer, while benefits given in kind reduce you to a supplicant. You can only consume the rice you are given or sell it; cash empowers you to do what you want with it.
Cash gives you more power and dignity than a free bag of rice handed over to you from a ration shop.
Sometimes, good solutions flow from the failure of bad ideas.
Support Swarajya's 50 Ground Reports Project & Sponsor A Story
Every general election Swarajya does a 50 ground reports project.
Aimed only at serious readers and those who appreciate the nuances of political undercurrents, the project provides a sense of India's electoral landscape. As you know, these reports are produced after considerable investment of travel, time and effort on the ground.
This time too we've kicked off the project in style and have covered over 30 constituencies already. If you're someone who appreciates such work and have enjoyed our coverage please consider sponsoring a ground report for just Rs 2999 to Rs 19,999 - it goes a long way in helping us produce more quality reportage.
You can also back this project by becoming a subscriber for as little as Rs 999 - so do click on this links and choose a plan that suits you and back us.
Click below to contribute.
Latest