'Bharat: India 2.0' Review: A Treatise On Bridging The Divide Between India's Modern State And Ancient Civilisation
The book 'Bhārat: India 2.0' is a scientist's look at the evolution of the modern Indian state and the ancient Bharatiya nation.
Bhārat: India 2.0. Gautam R Desiraju. Vitasta Publishing. 2022. Pages 396. Rs 750.
Jawaharlal Nehru, the first prime minister of India (or the second, if one counts Subhas Chandra Bose) often emphasised the borrowed Russellian term 'scientific temper'.
Out of its Christendom context, and grafted on to India, the term quickly devolved into a politically loaded way of denigrating Indian culture and civilisation.
The Nehruvian state created a vast array of vested interests in all domains that benefitted from a division created between the state and the nation.
While Nehru himself was not completely in agreement with the Marxist framework for India, later-day Nehruvianism made Marxism the only scientific way of looking at Indian history.
The state became all-powerful. A socialist state meant that it viewed traditional entrepreneurship in India with suspicion. A secular state meant that it obsessed with removing any semblance of India's ancient culture with its institutions.
The secular socialist state of India became a veritable circus rampant with corruption and communal identity politics, and overall a state that led society on a suicidal joy ride towards apocalypse.
Healing the dangerous festering divide between the anciently vibrant civilisational organism that is the nation 'Bharat' and the formidable state machine that is 'India' is a task that needs Bhagirathas.
Eminent scientist Dr Gautam Radhakrishna Desiraju has taken it upon himself, this sacred work of Bhagiratha.
The former president of the International Union of Crystallography, with a clarity of mind and a sword-sharp intellectual acumen both fundamental to a good scientist, weaves over 310 pages of text a narrative that is both holistic and robust, and, needless to say, empirically correct.
Sir Syed Ahmad Khan considered himself, up to a point, a Hindu Muslim. However, he changed over time and started batting for Islamist Muslim separatism. Dr Desiraju calls it the equivalent of "first order phase transition" (page 14).
Similarly, the brilliant chemist in Dr Desiraju provides striking parallels from his domain when articulating Dharmic vision and values. It is quite revealing to witness the resonance between Dharma and the basic laws of the universe.
Dharma is as fundamental to our existence as its converse in the physical world, the Second Law of Thermodynamics which governs the progression of things from order to randomness. Like the Second Law there will be many definitions of Dharma.Dr Gautam R Desiraju, 'Bhārat: India 2.0' (page 98)
Dharma has been the bedrock of this civilisation from the Upanishadic period, the author points out. Dharma reigns over rulers. From the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad to Shukra-niti and Sri Lalita Sahasranama, Dr Desiraju shows how Dharma is an important component of both secular and sacred realms in India.
Lest one thinks of Dharma as archaic and stagnant, he points out how Indian princely states, having roots in Dharma, enacted laws that were in tune with natural justice, as in the temple-entry proclamation of Travancore state.
Bhārat: India 2.0 is an important medicine for healing and harmonising the wound caused by Nehruvians and politicians with vested interests between the civilisational nation and the administrative state.
The administrative state, with its instruments of legislature, executive, and judiciary, should be in synchronisation with the ancient and alive nation. But it is not so in India. This is destroying us and making us waste the precious vital energy of national life.
In the competitive global arena, if we are to be taken seriously and even survive (as well as flourish), we need to heal this wound urgently, giving it all our energy. The book shows both the problem and the solution.
When one talks about civilisational continuity and the nation, discussing Hindutva is unavoidable. The author traces the origin of the term and explains in detail what it represents.
He uncompromisingly sees Hindutva as the surgical medicine and healing balm urgently needed to remove the self-inflicted festering wound between the nation and the state.
The book contains what is, perhaps, the most eloquent appreciation of Hindutva ever written after the crisp thesis of Veer Savarkar:
Hindutva is the single Sanskrit word that attempts to capture the instinctive nature of Bharatiya nationalism that Savarkar tried to define analytically and Ambedkar to articulate emotionally. ... Hindutva is nothing less or nothing more than feeling like a Hindu. ... Hindutva is a philosophy that can guide Bharat in this civilizational battle, a battle which she inherited through the misguided policies of our successive governments.Dr Gautam R Desiraju, 'Bhārat: India 2.0' (pages 232-33)
Constitutions, as mostly emerged from the early modernity of the West, are usually tools to enforce a 'civilising' unity from above. But in India, an ancient civilisational nation, such an imposed document can create more problems than solutions. Dr Desiraju explains:
It is critical to note that in a nation-state the people take their cue from the Constitution whereas in a civilizational state the Constitution flows from the nature of the people. In the latter, the Constitution is an outcome of national identity and not the rationale for it.Dr Gautam R Desiraju, 'Bhārat: India 2.0' (page 271)
So, how does civilisational national unity emerge from diversity?
Here, the book comes with an insightful parallel from the field of art — a technique developed by Georges Seurat and Pail Signac in the mid-1880s called Pointillism.
Bhārat: India 2.0 does not call for a conflict between the Constitution and the nation. On the other hand, it is a treatise on how both aspects can be made to have a constructive interference so we can reach great civilisational heights, which this nation and civilisation deserve.
The author ends the book reminding the reader of two laws — the Second Law of Thermodynamics and the Law of Dharma. The former relates to entropy, while the latter relates to an ever-expanding harmonious evolution.
It is Dharma which should be the basis of our civilisational nation-state. The author thinks this is happening now. We are in the midst of that churn.
We are at that point of the amrit kaal. And that is the Bharatiya Revolution. This book is an anthem and guide to that movement.
As you are no doubt aware, Swarajya is a media product that is directly dependent on support from its readers in the form of subscriptions. We do not have the muscle and backing of a large media conglomerate nor are we playing for the large advertisement sweep-stake.
Our business model is you and your subscription. And in challenging times like these, we need your support now more than ever.
We deliver over 10 - 15 high quality articles with expert insights and views. From 7AM in the morning to 10PM late night we operate to ensure you, the reader, get to see what is just right.
Becoming a Patron or a subscriber for as little as Rs 1200/year is the best way you can support our efforts.