Kolkata-Lhasa Highway: A Road To Prosperity For Both India And China
A highway from Kolkata to Lhasa is entirely possible, and could be beneficial, economically and strategically, to both India and China.
The Belt and Road Initiative, China’s quaintly named plan to redraw trading routes around the world, may have many shortcomings, but if adopted intelligently, can usher in a new age of economic prosperity in Eastern India. China has a huge East-West spread and its western part, the Tibet Autonomous Region, while rich in resources, has no access to the sea. Russia’s Siberian treasure house, which is similarly landlocked, will gradually get opened up as the Arctic polar cap melts and the Arctic ocean becomes navigable, but there is no such hope for Tibet. China knows this and also knows the importance of a route to the sea, which is why it is investing so heavily in its all-weather ally Pakistan.
The Karakoram Highway, the China Pakistan Economic Corridor, and the Gwadar Port are all pieces of the puzzle that China is trying to put together at great cost. But the cost is not so much in terms of money as it is in the way that it is forcing a great power like China to accept the diktats of Islamist terrorists like Masood Azhar. China knows that it cannot push a trade route through Pakistan without the blessings of the Islamists and it surely knows the terrible price that the Islamists will extract through the Uighur militancy in the far western Chinese province of Xinjiang. China is caught between the need to pander to the devil of Islamist terror and the need of a deep sea port to relieve the claustrophobia in landlocked Tibet. Is there an alternative? That is what we explore in this article.
The nineteenth century saw the British Empire locked in the Great Game with imperial Russia as both of them jostled for influence across the vast spaces of Central Asia. As part of this international political manoeuvring, Lord Curzon, the then Viceroy of India, decided to send a British mission under Colonel Francis Younghusband to Lhasa in Tibet. They departed from Calcutta in 1903, crossed over from Sikkim to Tibet at Nathu La, and after many battles and adventures, came back, apparently victorious, in 1904. The political outcome of this British mission to Tibet is no more of any relevance in the twenty-first century, but the fact that an army of 3,000 people along with another 5,000-odd camp followers could actually cross the highest mountain barrier twice, should be an eye-opener to anyone who dreams of trans-Himalayan trade routes.
Not having access to the vast resources of the British Empire, but seeking to recreate Younghusband’s route and relive his adventure, this author fired up Google Maps to see if there exists a motorable route that could take one from Kolkata to Lhasa. A straightforward request for directions obviously returns a negative, and Google admits that it cannot find a route from Kolkata to Lhasa. But a little tinkering with the map reveals a few interesting facts.
First, there is obviously a motorable road that connects Nathu La to Gangtok in Sikkim, then through National Highway 10 to the highway network in India and eventually to Kolkata about 800km and 20 hours away.
Second, the border post of Nathu La abuts the Chumbi Valley, just next to the Doklam Plateau of Tibet, where the Indian Army has been in confrontation with the Chinese army over the construction of a motorable road. But if we ignore this confrontation, then there exists a motorable road on the Chinese side.
Third, this Chinese highway, S204, that currently terminates at Yadong, is a part of the Chinese highway network and connects Yadong to Lhasa, which is about 400km or 10 hours away.
Finally, the distance between Nathu La, the last motorable point on the Indian side, and Yadong, the first motorable point on the Chinese side, is, as per Google Maps and “as the crow flies”, a minuscule 15km.
These four facts put together means that the 1,200km road from Kolkata to Lhasa is almost ready except for a 15km (or say 30km, since we cannot fly like a crow!) stretch between Nathu La in Sikkim and Yadong in Tibet!
From this perspective, should we in India object to China building a road in Doklam, or should we encourage them to do so? And create a great highway that connects Lhasa to Kolkata.
The benefits of such a highway are obvious. For the Chinese, it means an immediate access not just to India but through the Kolkata-Haldia dock system to the main shipping lines that connect Europe and Africa to the Far East. For Bengal and Kolkata, this could become a veritable blood transfusion for the rejuvenation of its ailing and anemic economic landscape, because Ray, Rabindranath, and rossogolla notwithstanding, maritime trade has always been the lifeblood of Kolkata and South Bengal.
Long, long ago, long before Kolkata or even Bengal existed, this part of the country was known for its maritime trade. Both Faxian and Xuanzang (whom our old history books would refer to as Fa-Hien and Hiuen Tsang), who came to India from China during the time of Harshavardhan, have left glowing reports about the great port of Tamralipta, which is identified with modern Tamluk in East Midnapur, on what is now known as the Rupnarayan river. With the siltation of the Rupnarayan, the port shifted to Satgaon, modern Saptagram, located on the Saraswati channel that broke off from the current Hooghly river channel at Tribeni and flowed through Singur – the tragic location of the aborted Tata Nano factory. Singur is perhaps where Bijoya Singha had set sail from to reach, occupy, and rule Sinhala or modern Sri Lanka. Subsequently, with the closure of the Saraswati channel, the Ganga waters switched back to what is now known as the Hooghly river and the British set up their trading post first in Hooghly, on the west bank, and when this was devastated by a cyclone, they moved to Calcutta – and the rest, as they say, is history.
The K G – King George’s – dock system of Calcutta became the heart of the vibrant economy of Bengal and eastern India until it received a body blow during the partition. Calcutta’s pre-eminence as a centre of trade and industry survived for another quarter of a century until it was finally done in by the communists who not only killed all industries but also devastated its educational institutions, spurring a near-complete exodus of intellectual capital. Commerce in Calcutta, now called Kolkata, is dominated in the present by an industrious tribe of up-country traders and in a fortuitous turn of events, it is these people who are best-placed to leverage a new trade route if it were to open up between Kolkata and Lhasa.
Some may be apprehensive that a highway like this would facilitate a Chinese military attack on India. This is unlikely in the twenty-first century. If the Lhasa-Kolkata highway were indeed to open up as a new “Silk Route”, the biggest beneficiary would be trade, but there could be a positive strategic dimension as well. If China sees this as a safe and secure route for its products to reach the sea, then its dependence on Pakistan will reduce and it will have the freedom to take a more honest view of the Islamist mischief that is being spawned at its western edge. A strong and powerful flow of money across the Himalayan border will automatically lead to a reduction of military hostility across the same because the interests of the trading community will have a moderating effect on the militarist nationalism of fringe groups. Chinese angst over its current border along the McMahon Line in Arunachal Pradesh may also be assuaged and its leadership would not lose face over its inability to occupy what they believe is Southern Tibet.
Would it lead to an increase in Chinese exports to India and have a negative impact on the balance of trade between the two countries? This is also unlikely. While trade is certainly facilitated by the ease of movement and cost of transport, the real driver for trade is the topology of demand and supply, and this will certainly not be impacted. The highway may impact traffic on other, longer, sea-based routes, but its impact on the overall volume may not be significant. On the other hand, given the lack of agricultural land in Tibet, there may be a market for the reverse flow of food products and fresh vegetables, and this may provide a fresh impetus to agricultural income in eastern India. Vegetable farmers in Bengal and Bihar may see a huge new market opening up through Nathu La.
What would it take to make this trade route operational? First, of course, the section from Nathu La to Yadong must be completed and we can be rest assured that the formidable Chinese border management machinery can make it happen in a short period. We are not aware of the condition of roads in Tibet, but certainly the existing motorable roads in Sikkim and Bengal need to be strengthened and widened. Between the Border Roads Organisation and the National Highway Authority of India, this, in principle, should not be a problem. The only big problem could be land acquisition in North Bengal, which is why it is important to have two alternate routes – the shorter route through Malda and Murshidabad, and the other slightly longer route that swings past Sahibganj and Dumka in Jharkhand before coming back through Birbhum. In fact, an inland port at Siliguri, which is already a big trading hub, would make matters much easier.
If and when the governments of India and China agree to rebuild and rejuvenate this ancient trade route, it would be appropriate to honour it with the names of Xuanzang, the Chinese pilgrim who came to the court of Harshavardhan in the seventh century, and Dipamkara Srijñana, the Buddhist scholar from Bengal whose visit to Tibet in the eleventh century is one of the greatest Buddhist legends of Tibet.
To get the ball rolling on the Dipamkara-Xuanzang Transhimalayan Expressway, the first and easiest thing would be to organise a Kolkata-to-Nathu La car and truck rally. This will not only fire up excitement and enthusiasm with all the stakeholders, but will also help us understand the operational challenges involved, at least in the first 800km. Will the different chambers of commerce that are headquartered in Kolkata take up this challenge?
As you are no doubt aware, Swarajya is a media product that is directly dependent on support from its readers in the form of subscriptions. We do not have the muscle and backing of a large media conglomerate nor are we playing for the large advertisement sweep-stake.
Our business model is you and your subscription. And in challenging times like these, we need your support now more than ever.
We deliver over 10 - 15 high quality articles with expert insights and views. From 7AM in the morning to 10PM late night we operate to ensure you, the reader, get to see what is just right.
Becoming a Patron or a subscriber for as little as Rs 999/year is the best way you can support our efforts.