Swarajya Logo
Swarajya Logo
Politics States Economy Society Business Culture Infra Defence World Books Ideas Science Technology Heritage Archives Legal Movies Sports
  • Our Views
    Politics States Economy Society Business Culture Infra Defence World Books Ideas Science Technology Heritage Archives Legal Movies Sports
  • Magazine
  • Store

About Swarajya

Swarajya is a publication by Kovai Media Private Limited.

Swarajya - a big tent for liberal right of centre discourse that reaches out, engages and caters to the new India.

editor@swarajyamag.com

Useful Links

  • About Us
  • Subscriptions Support
  • Editorial Philosophy
  • Press Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Code of Conduct
  • Plagiarism Policy
  • Refund & Cancellation Policy

Useful Links

  • About Us
  • Subscriptions Support
  • Editorial Philosophy
  • Press Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Code of Conduct
  • Plagiarism Policy
  • Refund & Cancellation Policy

Participate

  • Contact Us
  • Write for us
  • Style Guide
  • Jobs

Stay Connected

  • Artboard 2 Copy 6Created with Sketch.
    Artboard 2 Copy 10Created with Sketch.
    Artboard 2 Copy 7Created with Sketch.
    Artboard 2 Copy 9Created with Sketch.
  • Andriod Logo
  • IOS Logo

Economy

Do Coalitions Deliver Higher Growth? Data Doesn’t Support Y V Reddy’s Claims

R JagannathanTuesday, October 3, 2017 4:43 pm IST
Do coalitions and economic growth go hand in hand? (Photo: Virendra Singh Gosain/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)
Do coalitions and economic growth go hand in hand? (Photo: Virendra Singh Gosain/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)
Do coalitions and economic growth go hand in hand? (Photo: Virendra Singh Gosain/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)
  • In absolute contrast to Y V Reddy’s claims that coalition governments brought greater economic growth, India’s worst-ever performance was under its first coalition of sorts.
  • Last week, former Reserve Bank Governor Y V Reddy, made an astonishing claim: that economic growth has been better under coalition governments post-liberalisation.

    A report in The Economic Times quoted Reddy as saying: “Interestingly, the highest growth in India from 1990 to 2014 was really during coalition governments. So, in a way it is consensus based...in (the) Indian situation, a coalition probably produces better economic results than a strong government.”

    It is quite possible that Reddy’s questionable comments were made on the basis of the high growth rates achieved during United Progressive Alliance (UPA)-1. A closer look at the growth performances of single-party and coalition governments suggests that this generalisation has little basis in fact.

    Though Reddy’s comments relate to the post-liberalisation period, one could start with 1977, when the first major coalition government was sworn in at the centre. After that we had two strong single-party governments, those of Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi, which were the last major single-party governments we saw before Modi’s rise in 2014.

    While big bang reforms came in 1991, that was largely because we were about to go bust after the weak performance of the Rajiv Gandhi and VP Singh governments before that. We needed big changes to stay alive with an International Monetary Fund (IMF) loan.

    In 1977-80, when the Janata Party (it was actually a single party that behaved like a coalition) was in power under Morarji Desai and Charan Singh, the average growth rate for those three years was 2.6 per cent – even below the so-called Nehruvian “Hindu” growth rate. In fact, India suffered a massive negative growth under this coalition in 1979-80, when the gross domestic product (GDP) crashed to 5.2 per cent. The only other time we had negative growth was in 1972-73, but the drop was marginal at 0.3 percent under Indira Gandhi.

    So, India’s worst-ever performance was under its first coalition of sorts.

    Then we had four years of Indira Gandhi (1980-84), and the average growth rate was 5.9 per cent.

    Rajiv Gandhi’s five years (1984-89) recorded 5.2 per cent average; taken together, the nine years of Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi yielded an average of 5.5 per cent.

    Between 1989 and 1991, we had two coalitions, headed by minority parties under V P Singh and Chandra Shekhar; the batting average was 5.7 per cent. This is roughly midway between what Indira achieved and what Rajiv did with minor liberalisations.

    Then we had a minority government under P V Narasimha Rao, which gave us an average of 5.2 per cent. Yes, post-liberalisation, we saw growth fall below what Indira Gandhi, Rajiv and VP Singh achieved.

    In 1996-98, we had two United Front governments under Deve Gowda and IK Gujral, and the average moved up to 6.1 per cent.

    Atal Behari Vajpayee’s six-year tenure (1998-2004) gave us something similar, at 6 per cent.

    This growth uptick can be seen as the lag result of the 1991 reforms, which finally began to pay off in terms of an improved economic potential. We can hardly give coalitions the credit for this slight rise. In fact, oil sector deregulation and privatisation were shelved after some initial success in this regard. Coalitions proved to be a drag on liberalisation.

    The UPA tenure needs to be split into two parts – since there was a shift in growth calculation to the GVA (gross value added) method after 2011-12.

    In the first eight years, GDP growth under the old method averaged 8.3 per cent; in the final two years, GVA average was 5.7 per cent.

    The Narendra Modi government’s first three years gave us an average GVA growth rate of 7.3 per cent, but this may come down this year. We will have to wait till May 2019 to know how it did overall, but its performance on the first three years overshadows that of the UPA’s last two years.

    The high growth years of the UPA coincided with the big rise in global growth, where even sub-Saharan Africa did very well. If we exclude this extraordinary period, there is nothing at all to suggest that economic performance was higher when coalitions were in power as opposed to single-party governments.

    One can put the high growth years of UPA-1 to sheer luck, for no major reforms were undertaken. The growth surge lasted for a while as the government was on a spending spree in rural areas, and kept oil prices subsidised long after world prices had started moving up. In 10 years, the UPA paid out oil subsidies equivalent to Rs 840,000 crore, and topped that up with further excise stimulus of the order of Rs 180,000 crore. In short, UPA’s coalition era growth was built on steroids even when the global conditions were favourable. It had nothing to do with coalitions being more consensus driven; the only consensus was on allowing ministries to be run like private fiefs, including the money-spinning ones like telecom and coal. Corruption soared, and forced the next government to correct this loot.

    Coalition during the UPA years led to fiscal imprudence. Overspending and bad economic management led to a slowdown, from which we are still to recover. The single-party government of Modi inherited a seriously decelerating economy, but the change in method of calculating GDP lulled it into a false sense of complacence on growth. The slowdown relates to the delay in handling the crisis, not the nature of the government. It could have happened even if the BJP had led a coalition this time.

    Coalitions, or single-party governments, have less to do with economic performance than external conditions and internal reforms. Y V Reddy’s observations are not borne out by reality.

    (Note: A part of this article was first published by Dainik Bhaskar)

    Tags
    BJP
    Congress
    rajiv gandhi
    P V Narasimha Rao
    Indira Gandhi
    Morarji Desai
    Atal Behari Vajpayaee
    Chandra Shekhar
    Prime Minister Narendra Modi
    UPA-I & II
    Coalition
    Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
    Coalition government
    Janata Party
    V P SINGH

    Comments ↓

    An Appeal...


     

    Dear Reader,

     

    As you are no doubt aware, Swarajya is a media product that is directly dependent on support from its readers in the form of subscriptions. We do not have the muscle and backing of a large media conglomerate nor are we playing for the large advertisement sweep-stake.

     

    Our business model is you and your subscription.  And in challenging times like these, we need your support now more than ever.

     

    We deliver over 10 - 15 high quality articles with expert insights and views. From 7AM in the morning to 10PM late night we operate to ensure you, the reader, get to see what is just right.

     

    Becoming a Patron or a subscriber for as little as Rs 1200/year is the best way you can support our efforts.

    Get Swarajya in your inbox.


    Magazine


    Swarajya Magazine Cover Image
    Merchandise

    Merchandise


      Politics

      Not Like The Old Times: BJP's Feeble Victory In Rajasthan (Part I)

      Not Like The Old Times: BJP's Feeble Victory In Rajasthan (Part I)

      Venu Gopal Narayanan
      4h

      "Not Winning Solely On Modi's Popularity": Prashant Kishor Lists Out Four Reasons For BJP Victories In Three States

      Nishtha Anushree
      6h

      AIADMK Leadership Dispute: Madras High Court Rejects Sasikala's Bid For AIADMK Interim General Secretary Status

      Bhuvan Krishna
      9h

      Economy

      India Anticipated To Be Fastest Growing In Next Three Years, Set to Become Third Largest Economy By 2030: S&P

      India Anticipated To Be Fastest Growing In Next Three Years, Set to Become Third Largest Economy By 2030: S&P

      Nishtha Anushree
      10h

      Sensex Surpasses 69,000 For First Time As Investor Confidence Surges Post BJP Sweep In Three States

      Bhuvan Krishna
      12h

      Sensex, Nifty Close At All-Time High After BJP Victories In Three States, Record Surge Of Over 2 Per Cent

      Nishtha Anushree
      1d

      Defence

      On This Day, In 1971, Indian Navy Struck Pakistan's Naval Fleet At Karachi, Sank PNS Ghazi At Visakhapatnam, And Decimated Tanks In Longewala

      On This Day, In 1971, Indian Navy Struck Pakistan's Naval Fleet At Karachi, Sank PNS Ghazi At Visakhapatnam, And Decimated Tanks In Longewala

      Ujjwal Shrotryia
      7h

      On This Day, In 1971, Indian Air Force Struck Pakistani Installations For The Second Straight Day, Setting Stage For Historic Naval Raids On Karachi

      Ujjwal Shrotryia
      1d

      IAF's Mighty 'Mi-26,' Able To Lift Chinooks, Set For Overhaul With Russian Help

      Ujjwal Shrotryia
      1d

      World

      Moody's Downgrades China's Credit Ranking From Stable To Negative Citing Continuous Contraction Of Property Sector

      Moody's Downgrades China's Credit Ranking From Stable To Negative Citing Continuous Contraction Of Property Sector

      Nishtha Anushree
      7h

      Not Enough Joining US Military: Here's An Interesting Solution By A Senator — Let Illegal Immigrants Join, In Exchange For Citizenship

      Swarajya Staff
      12h

      Chinese Economic Crisis Deepens As Debt Defaults Reach Record High

      Swarajya Staff
      1d

      Culture

      'Celebrate At Home': Champat Rai Of Ram Janambhoomi Trust Urges Hindus Not To Visit Ayodhya On 22 January

      'Celebrate At Home': Champat Rai Of Ram Janambhoomi Trust Urges Hindus Not To Visit Ayodhya On 22 January

      Bhuvan Krishna
      13h

      'Animal': Sandeep Reddy Vanga 2 – Liberals 0

      K Balakumar
      3d

      Why The Insidious Anti-Hindu Communalism Of Certain Directors Goes Scot-Free

      Anonymous Contributor
      3d
      States

      infrastructure


      Arun Kumar Das
      1

      Delhi-Meerut-Ghaziabad RRTS: Power Supply Commences Beyond Priority Section On Rapid Rail Corridor

      2 Mins Read
      Amit Mishra
      2

      Groove On The Go: Delhi Metro Unveils Pilot Project For Audio Ads And Jingles

      1 Mins Read
      Amit Mishra
      3

      Vadnagar: Airport In The Works For PM Modi's Hometown, Central Team To Study Feasibility

      2 Mins Read
      Amit Mishra
      4

      Delhi-Meerut RRTS Corridor Achieves 67 Per Cent Completion, On Course For 2025 Deadline

      2 Mins Read