India’s Rs 20-Lakh-Crore Economic Package A Step In Right Direction For Supply-Side Relief, Govt Can Now Focus On Increasing Consumption
Government’s Rs 20 lakh crore economic package focusses largely on supply-side reforms and relief. It can now do more to increase liquidity in the hands of the middle class and taxpayers to drive consumption.
After the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Yojana (PMGKY) launched early in the lockdown to protect 80-crore of the most vulnerable citizens, the government has announced the Aatma Nirbhar Bharat Abhiyan (ANBA) — an Rs 20 lakh crore package combining reforms, and monetary and fiscal measures to make India self-reliant.
Various economic estimates place the fiscal impact of ANBA at 0.8-1.2 per cent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
The government has smartly focussed on some long-pending structural reforms and enhancing liquidity.
While some sections of the population are yet to receive relief, we must consider that no one knows for sure when the pandemic will end and economic operations will fully return.
It is possible the government is conserving resources at its disposal to be ready to invest more later.
Demand And Supply
ANBA focusses largely on supply-side reforms and relief. Medium, Small and Micro Enterprises, a section of manufacturers and employers, agricultural producers, Distribution Companies (DISCOMs), and other economic suppliers are rightfully beneficiaries.
The demand side needs support too, as an estimated 70 per cent of India’s economic growth since liberalisation has been fuelled by internal consumption.
With the loss of income and liquidity, crash in demand will impede growth.
Apart from increasing liquidity, the government could look at further reducing interest rates to increase borrowing, reducing taxes, and providing more direct income support.
Various countries around the world, including USA and Japan, have deployed a combination of these strategies.
The government’s next economic package, hopefully, can focus more on fiscal policies to increase liquidity in the hands of the middle class and taxpayers to drive consumption.
Economic Sector Impact Analysis
Agriculture: The government has announced large-scale reforms and investment in the sector. Rs 1.4 lakh crore is directed towards strengthening Agri-infrastructure, and various investments in micro-food clusters, livestock, medicinal plants, Operation Greens, and others.
These investments as well as liberalising trade by amending the Essential Commodities Act will go a long way in empowering farmers who now have long-awaited freedom to sell where they want.
Construction: One of the largest opportunities for growth and to provide mass employment after the pandemic is in construction and infrastructure projects. ANBA hasn’t addressed this sector yet, which could hopefully form a large part of the next package.
The government can enable National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), railways and other parastatals to pay off dues to contractors so these large employers have the liquidity to finance the next round of projects.
New projects need to be commissioned to sustain jobs.
Manufacturing: This sector has seen much relief. Manufacturing MSMEs can now avail of government-guaranteed loans totalling Rs 3.7 lakh crore. 75 per cent of India’s manufacturing jobs are though SMEs as per NITI-Aayog data, and this liquidity infusion will greatly help preserve them.
Further, the announcement of transformational reforms in coal, mining, defence production, and power can spur local manufacturing.
However, these are all capital-intensive industries. The government can consider a major economic package to similarly incentivise labour-intensive industries, especially in the highly-populous heartland states, to absorb excess labour locally.
This is especially needed to solve the migrant crisis. Flatted factories can be rapidly built and launched for this purpose.
Services: MSMEs in services sectors can avail loans, but large business operators have not seen much relief.
This is especially worrisome because most of the direct-impact sectors from Covid-19 are substantial employers — aviation, hospitality, restaurants, tourism, and others.
Without relief from the government, they have had to let go of many employees.
A special economic package including a one-year loan repayment deferment is required to tide them over until their operations start up again, which could take 6-9 months to get to even 50 per cent of normal operations in light of the pandemic.
Population Sections Impact Analysis
Farmers & rural workers: The first tranche of Rs 2,000 per beneficiary via PM-KISAN Yojana was front-loaded to provide minimum income support to farmers during the lockdown.
Agriculture operations were shielded and allowed to start up quickly. Many measures were taken to harvest the record-breaking rabi crop and sow the kharif on schedule.
Farmers can avail loans to the tune of Rs 2 lakh crore via the Kisan Credit Card scheme. Direct Benefit Transfer for MGNREGA was also issued in record time with an additional allocation of Rs 40,000 crore to provide cover to rural workers.
Migrants: Most states have not treated their migrant populations well, with many washing their hands off and blaming the Centre, resulting in an eye-opening crisis in the country.
ANBA has allotted Rs 3,500 crore worth of free food for migrants to be disbursed by state governments.
Two large issues remain — one, state governments hardly have any records of how many migrants are in their states, where they immigrated from, etc.
Lack of records makes it hard to distribute DBT and food to those in need.
A separate department is required to track migrant movement, just like NRI Affairs tracks non-resident Indians.
Two, a concerted effort to provide people with jobs in their own states is required to solve the migrant crisis permanently.
Small businesses: The differentiation between different MSMEs who can avail targeted loans, as well as the expanded definition of MSMEs, has helped.
With two months of economic lockdown inducing stress, it is suggested these funds be released quickly and banks be directed to lend as per the PM’s directives.
The move to clear IT, GST and customs duty refunds is also helpful.
Large businesses: Large business operators have not received much relief.
Many of them were hit by the pandemic-lockdown, as discussed under Services above.
Corporate revenues have reportedly dropped over 25 per cent during the lockdown and may take more than a year to recover.
To retain payroll and maintain liquidity to start operations as the lockdown lifts, large businesses still need relief and urgent tax refunds.
Reserve Bank of India can also offer a one-year loan repayment deferment to ensure liquidity.
Taxpayers: The 25 per cent reduction in TDS and TCS for non-salaried payments is a welcome move to increase short-term liquidity.
While this is applicable on payments for FY21, it does not address the loss of income due to the lockdown.
Tax refunds are being processed into the hands of non-corporates; corporates also need refunds to retain payroll, especially the IT industry. In terms of structural reforms, the long-pending move to a simplified three-slab system with no deductions from the current convoluted seven-slab system will provide more relief and make tax laws simpler.
Salaried individuals: In a 137-crore population in 2019, only 2.9 crore are salaried income-tax payers.
They have borne India’s high tax-burden for years and deserve support.
Sadly, they have not been included in the 25 per cent TDS reduction or fully in the accelerated processing of IT refunds.
US and Japan are giving direct cash support in the accounts of honest and compliant taxpayers to spur spending in a recessionary environment.
India also needs to take care of salaried taxpayers.
Investors: Investors, overwhelmingly middle-class, have been devastated by the dramatic decline of Rs 45 lakh crore in the stock market since the beginning of March. An estimated 3 crore investors through 9 crore folios have been impacted.
Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) investors are critical for domestic wealth creation — they had invested Rs 1 lakh crore in FY20 and were a counter to the Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs).
The best way to support wealth creators is to abolish long-term capital gains tax for individuals.
In AY19, out of Rs 45.3 lakh crore total income declared, LTCG by individuals was only Rs 67,000 crore.
At best, LTCG yielded Rs 13,000 crore tax out of a total Rs 8.9 lakh crore collected — barely 1.5 per cent. Abolishing individual LTCG tax will hardly impact government tax collections, but will have a tremendous feedforward wealth effect to drive spending.
Startups: Hardly any relief has reached startups. Government of India can capitalise Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI) in order to fund Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) to disburse money to startups.
Removing the LTCG tax can also help startups access capital from Indian investors. Reforms to incentivise insurance companies and other Indian institutional investors to pool money into Fund-of-Funds and direct investments are the need of the hour to keep India’s once-shining startup ecosystem afloat while the pandemic-lockdown goes through.
The PM’s ANBA programme is visionary and will have a substantial impact.
The Indian government has boldly prioritised lives first, and has now focussed on reforms to strengthen national economic security.
The middle class and direct-impact sectors now require measures to spur demand and boost morale urgently.
(This piece was first published here in The Sunday Guardian)
As you are no doubt aware, Swarajya is a media product that is directly dependent on support from its readers in the form of subscriptions. We do not have the muscle and backing of a large media conglomerate nor are we playing for the large advertisement sweep-stake.
Our business model is you and your subscription. And in challenging times like these, we need your support now more than ever.
We deliver over 10 - 15 high quality articles with expert insights and views. From 7AM in the morning to 10PM late night we operate to ensure you, the reader, get to see what is just right.
Becoming a Patron or a subscriber for as little as Rs 1200/year is the best way you can support our efforts.