Ideas
On Police’s Rebuttals Of The Wire And IANS Reports And Leftist Media’s Silence On it
Swarajya Staff
Apr 13, 2020, 07:30 PM | Updated 10:02 PM IST
Save & read from anywhere!
Bookmark stories for easy access on any device or the Swarajya app.
Recently, the state police of Punjab and Uttar Pradesh, through their official Twitter handles, have refuted two separate reports by portal Thewire.in and news agency IANS, respectively.
Curiously, there has been a near total silence of the Leftist media, that dominates the news industry, on these rebuttals.
This is in sharp contrast to cases in the recent past where the same media attacked publications whose reports were similarly rebutted by the police.
We, at Swarajya, are documenting this to show the Leftist media and ideologically aligned fact-checkers’ bias in reporting about police rebuttals to media reports.
For the record, we do not consider police rebuttals by themselves alone as fact-checks or irrefutable truths.
Punjab police call report by The Wire as fake
On 8 April, the publication carried a report titled ‘Punjab: Muslims Families Hide in Riverbed After Being Driven From Hoshiarpur Villages’. The report was written by a reporter named Prabhjit Singh.
“Several children, women and men on Wednesday continued to hide themselves in the Swan riverbed, without food for three days now, on the Punjab side of the state’s marshy borders with Himachal Pradesh. They were allegedly abused, beaten and chased away from their mud-house settlements in villages in the Talwara block of Hoshiarpur district,” the report said.
Siddharth Varadarajan, chief editor of Thewire.in, then tweeted out the report on his account.
The official handle of Hoshiarpur Police, @PP_Hoshiarpur, however said it is “fake news”. The handle also asked Varadarajan to not post articles that create panic among the people in the time of crisis.
Its fake! Please donât post such articles that create panic among people in this time of crisis. We need to UNITE AND FIGHT this pandemic n should help to aware people...NOT to panic.
— Hoshiarpur Police (@PP_Hoshiarpur) April 9, 2020
The handle also posted videos of some Gujjars, who the ‘thewire.in’ had reported were beaten up and were surviving without food, saying that they were getting supplies from the government.
ððððððð ððð ðððð.
— Hoshiarpur Police (@PP_Hoshiarpur) April 9, 2020
ðððâð ðððððð ð ððð ðððð. pic.twitter.com/3UVxUYTkGH
In some truly harsh words, Surendra Lamba, an IPS officer, replied to Varadarajan’s post saying, “Responsible People Should Behave More Responsible at the times of such crisis. Must avoid posting Facts/News which is not authentic and can create panic among communities. Good job @PP_Hoshiarpur.”
Responsible People Should Behave More Responsible at the times of such crisis. Must avoid posting Facts/News which is not authentic and can create panic among communities. Good job @PP_Hoshiarpur https://t.co/NttJqay7gr
— Surendra Lamba,IPS (@IPSSLamba) April 9, 2020
It was only on 13 April that Varadarajan posted the portal’s answer to the allegations of fake news.
Folks trying to suggest the story Prabhjit Singh did for @thewire_in on the harassment of Gujjars in Hoshiarpur, Punjab is "fake news", please see the videos we have posted of lathi wielding folks in this story! This was shot with actors in a studio?! https://t.co/Lmw85vmZoM 1/8
— Siddharth (@svaradarajan) April 13, 2020
UP police call report by IANS as fake
On 12 April, news agency IANS published a report titled ‘In A Shocking Incident, Mother In UP Throws 5 Children Into River’. The report was carried by a number of publications including Outlookindia.com, Indiatvnews.com, Businessinsider.in and India Today-owned Lallantop.
Many influential social media users including Kavita Krishna amplified it.
On 13 April, the official handle of Bhadohi police refuted the report. The handle said that the mother, Manju Devi, indeed threw the children in the river but did so not out of hunger but after a fight with her husband.
मà¤à¤à¥ दà¥à¤µà¥ नॠठपनॠ05 बà¤à¥à¤à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤à¥à¤à¤®à¤°à¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤°à¤£ à¤à¤à¤à¤¾ नदॠमà¥à¤ नहà¥à¤ डà¥à¤¬à¤¾à¤¯à¤¾ हà¥à¥¤à¤ नà¥à¤¯ à¤à¤¾à¤°à¤£ दà¥à¤µà¤¾à¤°à¤¾ à¤à¤à¤¨à¤¾ à¤à¥ ठà¤à¤à¤¾à¤® दिया à¤à¤¯à¤¾ हà¥à¥¤ मà¤à¤à¥ दà¥à¤µà¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤° मà¥à¤ à¤à¤¾à¤¨à¤¾ बना हॠफà¥à¤à¥ सॠसà¥à¤ªà¤·à¥à¤ हॠà¤à¤¿ à¤à¥à¤à¤®à¤°à¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤°à¤£ बà¤à¥à¤à¥à¤ à¤à¥ नदॠमà¥à¤ नहà¥à¤ डà¥à¤¬à¤¾à¤¯à¤¾ à¤à¤¯à¤¾ हà¥à¥¤@Uppolice @adgzonevaranasi @digmirzapur pic.twitter.com/z0yE0DDXiJ
— BHADOHI POLICE (@bhadohipolice) April 13, 2020
The handle also posted the statement of the investigating police officer saying the same.
@bhadohipolice मà¤à¤à¥ दà¥à¤µà¥ ठपनॠपति à¤à¥ विवाद à¤à¤µà¤ मानसिठतनाव à¤à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤°à¤£ ठपनॠपाà¤à¤à¥ बà¤à¥à¤à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤à¤à¤à¤¾ नदॠमà¥à¤ डà¥à¤¬à¥ दिया। मà¤à¤à¥ दà¥à¤µà¥ सॠपà¥à¤à¤¤à¤¾à¤ à¤à¥ à¤à¤ à¤à¤¿à¤¸à¤®à¥à¤ पà¥à¤²à¤¿à¤¸ ठधà¥à¤à¥à¤·à¤ à¤à¤¦à¥à¤¹à¥ दà¥à¤µà¤¾à¤°à¤¾ दॠà¤à¤ बाà¤à¤à¥¤ pic.twitter.com/ThjyIHu6LW
— BHADOHI POLICE (@bhadohipolice) April 13, 2020
It is a stand of Swarajya that police rebuttals are not fact-checks by themselves. They are merely police’s versions and are open to further scrutiny.
However, fact-checking portals repeatedly use police rebuttals to put the “fake news” label on publications or reports they don’t agree with.
Recently, such portals gave wide coverage to the police rebuttal of a tweet by news agency ANI.
The agency corrected its information after the police’s reply, but faced a massive smear campaign for the error.
As Swarajya earlier reported, the same portals ignored a gave error by news agency PTI where it had declared a Muslim man dead when he was alive. The story was about a communal attack.
Altnews.in recently published a report where it cited a rebuttal by Saharanpur police to reports by Amar Ujala and Patrika. The portal, without carrying the version of the publications, termed their reports as “misreporting”.
It is also being repeatedly seen that police rebuttals of any report involving Tablighi Jamaat or Muslims are being cited as fact-checks and their publishers are being subjected to massive trolling, where rebuttals of other reports are being ignored.
Save & read from anywhere!
Bookmark stories for easy access on any device or the Swarajya app.
Introducing ElectionsHQ + 50 Ground Reports Project
The 2024 elections might seem easy to guess, but there are some important questions that shouldn't be missed.
Do freebies still sway voters? Do people prioritise infrastructure when voting? How will Punjab vote?
The answers to these questions provide great insights into where we, as a country, are headed in the years to come.
Swarajya is starting a project with an aim to do 50 solid ground stories and a smart commentary service on WhatsApp, a one-of-a-kind. We'd love your support during this election season.
Click below to contribute.